Secured loan or remortgage: which suits you?
A remortgage replaces your whole mortgage with a new, larger one. A secured loan leaves your mortgage alone and adds a separate loan on top. Remortgaging often suits people whose current deal is ending. A secured loan often suits people who would pay a charge to leave their deal, or who want to keep the rate they have.
In this guide
What is the difference?When does a remortgage tend to fit?When does a secured loan tend to fit?How do you compare the cost?Questions people askWhat is the difference?
With a remortgage you move your mortgage to a new deal, either with your current lender or a new one, and borrow extra at the same time. You end up with one loan and one monthly payment.
With a secured loan, also called a second charge mortgage, your existing mortgage stays exactly as it is. A second lender provides the extra money and you make a second monthly payment alongside your mortgage.
| Remortgage | Secured loan | |
|---|---|---|
| Your current mortgage | Replaced by a new one | Stays as it is |
| Monthly payments | One | Two |
| Early repayment charge on your mortgage | May apply if you leave your deal early | Not triggered, because the mortgage is untouched |
| How long it takes | Often several weeks | Often quicker, as there is less legal work |
| Interest rates | Usually lower | Usually higher than a first mortgage |
When does a remortgage tend to fit?
- Your fixed or tracker deal is ending in the next few months, so there is no charge for leaving.
- You are on your lender’s standard variable rate and free to move.
- You want one payment and are happy to review the whole mortgage.
Because the new rate applies to everything you owe, a remortgage is worth comparing carefully if your current rate is lower than the rates on offer today.
When does a secured loan tend to fit?
- You are part way through a fixed deal and leaving it would mean an early repayment charge.
- Your current mortgage rate is low and you would rather not lose it.
- Your circumstances have changed since you took the mortgage, for example you are now self-employed, and your own lender will not lend more.
- You need the money sooner than a remortgage would allow.
How do you compare the cost?
Look at the total you would repay under each option, not only the monthly payment. For a remortgage, include any early repayment charge, the new lender’s fees and legal costs. For a secured loan, include the lender and broker fees.
The APRC on each quote rolls the interest and fees into one yearly figure, which makes two different deals easier to line up. An adviser can work out both routes for you and recommend the one that suits your circumstances.
If you borrow £18,000 over 10 years, initially on a fixed rate for 5 years at 7.4% and for the remaining 5 years on the lender's standard variable rate of 7.9%, you would make 60 monthly payments of £249.27 and 60 monthly payments of £254.63. The total amount of credit is £19,657 (including a lender fee of £595 and a broker fee of £1,062). The total amount repayable would be £30,234. The overall cost for comparison is 10.42% APRC representative. This means 51% or more of customers receive this rate or better for this type of product. Secured loan terms: minimum 36 months to maximum 360 months (3 to 30 years). Maximum APRC charged 29%. If you are thinking of consolidating existing borrowing, you should be aware that you may be extending the terms of the debt and increasing the total amount you repay.
Questions people ask
Is a secured loan more expensive than a remortgage?
The interest rate on a secured loan is usually higher than on a first mortgage. It can still cost less overall if remortgaging would mean paying an early repayment charge or moving your whole mortgage onto a higher rate. The only way to know is to compare the total cost of both.
Can I have a secured loan and remortgage later?
Yes. When you remortgage in future you can often repay the secured loan as part of the new mortgage, so you are back to one payment. Check whether the secured loan has its own early repayment charge.
Do both use my home as security?
Yes. Both are secured on your property, so your home is at risk if you do not keep up the repayments on either.